Love

10/30/2012

2 Comments

 
There is a girl at work who Winston hates. He hates her because she is young, beautiful, and belongs to the Anti-Sex League. He wants to have sex with someone attractive and alive, unlike his estranged wife, and this girl has dedicated her life to making this impossible. One day she falls in the hallway next to him, and as he helps her up, she slips him a note. He reads it at his desk and it reads simply "I love you." (108) 

Quote: I chose this quote because it is monumental. If I were reading an escapist romance, I would obviously not consider a confession of love monumental, but that it came out of the gray, listless world of "1984" is astounding. I can imagine that this is why Orwell included this plot. The introduction of humanity is what gives us hope for Winston, but it is ultimately the center of the bleak message of "1984." The purpose of this quote is to create a rose growing in the cracks of the cement.

Analysis: In literary terms, this could be considered the beginning of the "rising action." After Winston and Julia (the name of the girl, we learn later) hook up, the plot accelerates quickly. The writer's craft for this quote is interesting. While in and of itself, "I love you" is not exactly a novel phrase, in this instance they are incredibly exciting. Orwell creates this using suspense, first shocking us with the note being slipped, then building up Winston's curiosity as he must wait to read it to avoid suspicion from the Thought Police, and, finally, letting us read the note, with Winston. Orwell also presents the words from the note in the same way that he presents the Party Slogan: centered and separated from the text by at least one line, except that he put in cursive, which effectively conjures handwriting, and that it attempts to refute everything that the Party Slogan stands for.  
Nick
10/31/2012 01:21:30 am

but does it refute all of the party slogans? It is natural for physical attraction to occur, but the idea of love is so subjective to each person.

Reply
10/31/2012 12:41:12 pm

The meaning of the first part of the Party slogan, "Freedom is Slavery," is that to limit yourself to a single being is only being a slave to your flaws. If that is true, to feel a singular emotion, such as love, is to become the slave of freedom that the Party is talking about. The Party would demands that you are not a person, because as a person you are fallible. They say you are a cell in an organism. If cells began to have feelings they would begin to fight inside our bodies, compete. Then we would end up with not only auto-immune diseases, but auto-physiological diseases. We would decay into nothing within a week. If you think of cells as lasting 50-60 years, as people have throughout most of history, how different are our ancient civilizations? How different are we?

Reply



Leave a Reply.